Table 2

Characteristics of studies included in systematic review

First authorYearCountryTimeSettingSpecialtyRespondent(s)PatientsPatient age(years)Male patients (%)
Mahes A.2023USA1 yearHospital outpatientUnselectedPhysicians30174.7±8.267.1
Lin C.A.2023Brazil1 yearHospital outpatientGeneral medicinePhysicians84060.9±14.931.9
Um Y.W.2023South Korea30-daysEmergency departmentUnselectedPhysicians30070.5 (59.3–81.8)54
DogbeyD.M.2022South Africa6 monthsInpatientOncologyPhysicians4358 (45–68)35
Kim S.H.2022South Korea7 days21-days42-daysInpatientOncologyPhysicians13066.0±12.250.8
Maes H.2022Belgium1 yearHospital inpatientUnselectedCardiologyPhysicians381Not reported81.4
Gaffney L.2022Ireland1 yearEmergency departmentUnselectedPhysicians19179 (74–83)45
Ikari T.2021Japan, Korea, Taiwan1 dayInpatientOncologyPhysicians141172.6±12.250.7
Ikari T.2021Japan, Korea, Taiwan3 daysInpatientOncologyPhysicians141172.6±12.250.7
Moor C.C.2021Netherlands1 yearOutpatientRespiratoryPhysiciansSpecialist nurses14074.0±6.587.1
Gonzalez- Jaramillo V.2021Colombia1 yearOutpatientCardiologyPhysicians17470 (58–77)55.2
Tripp D.2021USA30 days1-yearInpatientRespiratoryPhysiciansAdvanced practice providers428Not reported49.1
ErmersD.J.M.2021Netherlands1 yearHospital outpatientOncologyPhysiciansTrainee physicians37959.4±1555.7
Yarnell C.2021Canada1 yearHospital inpatientGeneral medicinePhysiciansTrainee physicians41775 (60–85)52.0
Ros M.M.2021Netherlands2 days10-days1-yearIntensive care unitUnselectedPhysicians314063.5±16.657.1
Flierman I.2020Netherlands1 yearInpatientUnselectedNurses23481.2±6.648.4
Van WijmenM.P.S.2020Netherlands1 yearPrimary careUnselectedPhysicians57Not reported28.4
Ramer S.J.2020USA2 yearsHospital outpatientNephrologyPhysiciansAdvanced practitioners37772 (66–78)49
Lai C.-F.2020Taiwan1 yearHospital outpatientNephrologyNurses40156.2±1449.9
Rauh L.A.2020USA1 yearHospital outpatientOncologyPhysicianNurseAdvanced practice providers358Not reportedNot reported
Yen Y.-F.2020Taiwan1 yearHospital inpatientUnselectedNurses21 09862.8±19.053.2
Ouchi K.2019USA30-daysEmergency departmentUnselectedPhysicians10 73775.9±8.848.5
Verhoef M.J.2019Netherlands1 yearEmergency departmentOncologyPhysicians24562 (45–79)48
AaronsonE.L.2019USA1 yearEmergency departmentCardiologyPhysicians19374.5±12.6
SchmidtR.J.2019USA1 yearHospital outpatientNephrologyPhysiciansTrainee physiciansNurse practitioners74969.3±14.650.9
Lakin J.R.2019USA2 yearsPrimary carePrimary carePhysiciansNurses2611Not reported40.9
VeldhovenC.M.M.2019Netherlands1 yearPrimary careUnselectedPhysicians29284±5.540.1
Haydar S.A.2019USA30-daysEmergency departmentUnselectedPhysicians612266 (51–79)51.7
Straw S.2019UK1 yearHospital inpatientCardiologyPhysiciansTrainee-physiciansNursesNurse practitioners12971±1464
Rice J.2018Canada3 monthsNursing homeUnselectedPhysicians30185.9±9.067.8
6 monthsNursesSupport workers
Burke K.2018UK90 days1-yearHospicePaediatricPhysicians Nurses Administrators3277.6±5.356.6
Ouchi K.2018USA1 yearEmergency departmentUnselectedPhysicians20775±7.551.2
Liyanage T.2018Australia1 yearNursing homeUnselectedNurses18782.4±9.144.4
MitchellG.K.2018Australia1 yearPrimary careUnselectedPhysicians4365Not reportedNot reported
Ebke M.2018Germany1 yearHospital outpatientNeurorehabilitationPhysicians23663±1457.7
Mudge A.M.2018Australia1 yearHospital inpatientUnselectedPhysiciansNurses10060.2±18.953.8
GuliniJ.E.H.M.B.2018Brazil1 dayIntensive care unitUnselectedPhysicians17057±15.651.2
Salat H.2017USA1.9 yearsHospital outpatientNephrologyPhysician48871 (65–77)49
Malhotra R.2017USA6 months1-yearHospital outpatientNephrologyPhysician215Not reported55
Hadique S.2017USA6 monthsIntensive care unitUnselectedPhysician1043Not reported53.7
Gomez- Batiste X.2017Spain1 year2-yearsPrimary care Hospital outpatient Intermediate care centre Nursing homeUnselectedPhysician/nurse1059Not reportedNot reported
Javier A.D.2017USA1 yearHospital outpatientNephrologyPhysiciansTrainee physiciansNurse practitioners38871 (65–77)49.7
Amro O.W.2016USA1 yearHospital outpatientNephrologyPhysicians2016652.2
Lakin J.R.2016USA1 yearPrimary careUnselectedPhysicians17376539.7
Carmen J.2016Spain1 yearHospital outpatientNephrologyPhysicians49Not reportedNot reported
Hamano J.2015Japan7 days30-daysHospital and community palliative careOncologyPhysicians236169.1±12.857.5
Feyi K.2015UK1 yearHospital outpatientNephrologyPhysiciansNurses1787263.2
Moroni M.2014Italy1 yearPrimary carePrimary care/oncologyPhysicians23170.2 (SE 0.9)50.6
O'CallaghanA.2014New Zealand6 months1-yearHospital inpatientAcute medicinePhysiciansNurse practitioners501Not reportedNot reported
Da SilvaGane M.2013UK1 yearHospital outpatientNephrologyPhysicianNurses3896Not reportedNot reported
Pang W.-F.2013China1 yearHospital outpatientNephrologyPhysicians36760.2±12.355.9
Haga K.2012UK1 yearHospital outpatientCardiologyNurses13877±1066
Fenning S.2012UK1 yearHospital outpatientCardiologyPhysicians17266±1461
Moss A.H.2010USA1 yearHospital outpatientOncologyPhysicians826Not reportedNot reported
Cohen L.M.2010USA6 monthsHospital outpatientNephrologyPhysicians450Not reported56.7
Moss A.H.2008USA1 yearHospital outpatientNephrologyPhysicians14766.4±14.855.1
Barnes S.2008UK1 yearPrimary careCardiologyPhysicians2317754.1
  • Age is displayed as mean±SD deviation or median (IQR) where available.