Table 1

Number of papers included in the current synthesis and original review

Review questionNumber of papers in the current review answering each research question and overall WoE (D) scoresNumber of papers in original review23 answering each research question and overall WoE (D) scores*
What is current practice?21 papers: 6 high, 11 medium and 4 low WoE (D) scores26 papers: 3 high, 16 medium and 7 low WoE (D) scores
What are the attitudes of patients?1 paper: high WoE (D) scoreNo papers on patient views or experiences. 2 papers refer to practitioner interpretations of patient views: 1 medium and 1 low overall WOE (D) scores
What are the attitudes of family caregivers?9 papers: 2 high, 5 medium and 2 low WoE (D) scores5 papers: 2 medium and 3 low overall WoE (D) scores
What are the attitudes of community healthcare professionals?15 papers: 5 high, 8 medium and 2 low WoE (D) scores21 papers: 3 high, 13 medium and 5 low overall WoE (D) scores
What is its impact on patient comfort and symptom control?2 papers: 1 high and 1 medium WoE (D) scores3 papers: 2 medium and 1 low overall WoE (D) scores
Is it cost-effective?3 papers: 3 medium WoE (D) scores9 papers: 6 medium and 3 low overall WoE (D) scores
  • *Studies from the original review23 were not included in the results and narrative synthesis: they are detailed in the table to give an overview of the overall evidence base.

  • WoE, Weight of Evidence.