Table 3

Coprimary and secondary outcomes by trial arm

OutcomeMean (SE)Adjusted trial arm effect
RDSIControlβ95% CIP value*
Breathlessness (Dyspnoea-12)
 Baseline16.71 (0.93)15.31 (0.91)
 4 weeks12.86 (1.20)14.95 (1.14)−3.15−5.82 to −0.480.021
 12 weeks11.45 (1.31)14.35 (1.14)−4.13−7.09 to −1.180.007
Cough (MCLC)
 Baseline13.69 (0.88)13.95 (0.92)
 4 weeks11.10 (1.09)15.28 (1.04)−4.02−6.37 to −1.680.001
 12 weeks8.47 (1.29)14.04 (1.08)−5.49−8.43 to −2.55<0.001
Fatigue (FACIT-F)
 Baseline24.32 (0.99)24.07 (1.07)
 4 weeks27.42 (1.69)23.90 (1.36)3.47−0.38 to 7.310.077
 12 weeks28.62 (2.09)23.72 (1.44)4.910.24 to 9.570.039
NRS coping with symptoms (breathlessness)
 Baseline6.29 (0.23)6.09 (0.20)
 4 weeks6.67 (0.34)5.77 (0.30)0.81−0.03 to 1.650.424
 12 weeks6.97 (0.39)5.85 (0.35)1.070.13 to 2.010.026
NRS coping with symptoms (cough)
 Baseline6.43 (0.26)6.36 (0.25)
 4 weeks7.12 (0.41)6.29 (0.34)0.78−0.21 to 1.770.120
 12 weeks7.41 (0.45)6.28 (0.39)1.180.07 to 2.300.037
NRS coping with symptoms (fatigue)
 Baseline4.97 (0.24)5.29 (0.24)
 4 weeks5.96 (0.41)5.17 (0.29)0.960.03 to 1.890.042
 12 weeks5.78 (0.48)5.25 (0.37)0.62−0.52 to 1.760.284
HADS Questionnaire: Anxiety
 Baseline7.33 (0.42)6.81 (0.43)
 4 weeks6.81 (0.60)7.73 (0.46)−1.32−2.53 to −0.120.031
 12 weeks6.40 (0.57)7.19 (0.52)−1.20−2.45 to 0.050.061
HADS Questionnaire: Depression
 Baseline6.91 (0.34)7.16 (0.36)
 4 weeks7.13 (0.51)7.69 (0.44)−0.40−1.54 to 0.730.482
 12 weeks6.90 (0.73)7.63 (0.53)−0.60−2.28 to 1.090.482
  • Unadjusted means and standard errors for coprimary and secondary outcomes by trial arm and time point derived from 100 imputation sets. Adjusted trial arm effects from ANCOVA models are also provided at 4 and 12 weeks, respectively.

  • *Reference two-tail significance levels are (2*0.05/3) = 0.033 for the 3 coprimary outcomes (Breathlessness, Cough and Fatigue) and 0.05 for secondary outcomes.

  • ANCOVA, analysis of covariance; FACIT-F, Functional Assessment of Chronic Illness-Fatigue; HADS, Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale; MCLC, Manchester Cough in Lung Cancer; NRS, Numerical Rating Scale; RDSI, respiratory distress symptom intervention.