Table 1

Summary of included studies

Study nameIntervention total daily dose (mg)Comparison group(s)Underlying conditionParticipants (n)Length of trial (weeks)Jadad score
Randomised control trials vs placebo
 Monfared et al2MA
80
PlaceboESRF2283
 Von Roenn et al27MA
100 v 400 v 800
Four-arm trial*AIDS270123
 Weisberg et al28MA
800
PlaceboCOPD14583
 Yeh et al29MA
800
PlaceboGeriatric cachexia69125
Randomised control trials vs other interventions
 Batterham and Garsia30MA
400
Three-arm trial:†HIV15122
 Mulligan et al31MA
800
MA plus‡HIV79125
 Mwamburi et al32MA plus dietary advice
800
OxandroloneHIV3983
 Rochon et al33Medroxyprogesterone plus§
400
Placebo plus§HIV1253
 Summerbell et al34MA
40 plus¶
CyproheptadineHIV14121
 Timpone et al35MA
750
Four-arm trial:**HIV50122
 Wanke et al36MA concentrated solution
575 v 800
Oral solution (800 mg OD)HIV63123
 Yeh et al37MA
800
MA plus††ESRF9245
Non-randomised trials
 Gołębiewska et al38MA
160
ESRF32Up to 6 months (analysis at 8 weeks)
 Graham et al39MA
800
AIDS143
 Lien and Ruffenach40MA
40
ESRF168
 Mwamburi et al41MA plus‡‡
800
HIV297 months
 Rammohan et al42MA
400
ESRF1616
 Von Roenn et al43MA
320 plus§§
HIV22Up to 72 weeks
  • *(a) 100 mg OD, (b) 400 mg OD, (c) 800 mg OD and (d) placebo.

  • (a) Dietary counselling (b) nandrolone decanoate (100 mg/fortnight intramuscular injection) (c) megestrol acetate (400 mg/day oral).

  • ‡MA plus testosterone versus MA plus placebo.

  • §Nutritional support, amino acid supplementation and protein drinks.

  • ¶Increased by 40 mg alternate weeks to maximum dose of 160 mg if no weight gain.

  • **(a) Dronabinol 2.5 mg BD, (b) MA 750 mg OD, (c) MA 750 OD plus dronabinol 2.5 mg BD and (d) MA 250 mg OD plus dronabinol 2.5 mg OD.

  • ††Physical training versus placebo plus physical training.

  • ‡‡Dietary advice plus oxandrolone.

  • §§Increased by 140 mg if no weight gain after 12 weeks.

  • COPD, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease; ESRF, end-stage renal failure; MA, megestrol acetate.