Article Text

Download PDFPDF

56 Are there inappropriate palliative patient deaths in emergency departments (ed)? a retrospective study looking at the deaths in a district general hospital ed
  1. Hannah Fox,
  2. Matthew Doré and
  3. Derek Willis
  1. Severn Hospice, Shrewsbury and Telford NHS Trust


Introduction Palliative patients sometimes present to emergency departments when dying and current policy aims to reduce such unnecessary admissions. This study provides a description of palliative care related deaths in an ED and an assessment of how many of these were preventable.

Methodology 32 consecutive deaths were reviewed in a district general ED department in Shropshire during 2016/2017. Death certification details, palliative status and DNACPR status were identified. We retrospectively judged whether their admission was potentially avoidable.


  • Median age 83 years (range 40–95)

  • 15 female patients (47%).

EpidemiologyMode of death

  • 12 patients died from respiratory pathology (37%), 6 from cardiac (18%), 6 from gastrointestinal (18%), 3 from infection (9%), 3 from stroke (9%), 1 from cancer (3%) and 2 were uncategorised.

  • Frailty and palliative status

  • Frailty and old age was documented on 10 death certificates (29%), dementia on 3 (9%).

  • 4 patients (12%) had oncological disease.

  • 2 patients (6%) were known to be palliative, 16 patients (50%) were not. There is uncertainty regarding the palliative status of the remaining patients and clarification using the gold standard framework is ongoing.

  • 25 patients were DNACPR (81%).

We believe 3 admissions were preventable (9%), 17 were unavoidable (53%) and the remaining 12 are unclear (38%).

Conclusion This study suggests that some palliative patients do present to ED and die, and that some of these admissions were avoidable. With ever increasing ED pressures we suggest it’s imperative to understand the reasons, assess the scale, and find solutions to inappropriate palliative ED admissions.

Statistics from

Request Permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.